The Settlement Bar & Grill Green Bay
The Settlement Bar & Grill Logo

The Settlement Bar & Grill

4.6786 reviews

The Settlement Bar & Grill stands as a historic gem in Green Bay's Eastside. This family-friendly establishment invites diners to relax in a cozy atmosphere.

Famous for its hearty fish fry and delicious old fashions, this bar and grill excels in creating memorable dining experiences.

Locals and visitors can enjoy a welcoming vibe, exceptional service, and great food any day of the week. The Settlement has managed to keep a neighborhood charm that draws people back regularly.

With offerings like the monster burger and tacos, the restaurant caters to diverse tastes. Plus, the specials provide great value for families and solo diners alike.

About

Nestled on Bay Settlement Road, The Settlement Bar & Grill has carved a niche in the hearts of Green Bay residents. Its rich history adds character to each visit, making it more than just a restaurant.

Originally opening decades ago, this spot gained recognition through generations of fish fries and timeless cocktails. Over time, it has evolved while maintaining its traditional roots.

After recent remodeling, the place has become even more inviting. The cozy seating and warm décor welcome guests to feel right at home.

Local artwork and photographs enhance the ambiance. They tell the story of the community’s connection to this beloved establishment.

Get in Touch

3254 Bay Settlement Rd, Green Bay, WI 54311, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 11:00-19:00
  • Tuesday 11:00-22:00
  • Wednesday 11:00-22:00
  • Thursday 11:00-22:00
  • Friday 11:00-22:00
  • Saturday 11:00-23:00
  • Sunday 09:00-19:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Been a local for years, The New Settlement does not disappoint, I had the monster burger for 13.00 and was not disappointed for the price, My girlfriend had the chicken tender basket and was a great amount of food for the price, all in all the service is great, atmosphere is warm and friendly! And the staff is 5 star service! Well worth the stop in! Attached I have the specials menu aswell!"

- Gabe L.

"My family loves the fish fry- perch and haddock. And we sure enjoy Taco Tuesday. The cochinita pibil tacos are delicious! Great variety from the Settlement. So glad to have them in the neighborhood"

- Gregg S.

"The fish fry is great, but they ran out of baked potatoes. Fine with me. I prefer baby reds or fries anyway. Who wants a boring old brown potato? Everyone else, I guess. My uncle had the double order of perch and said it was "almost too much." My mom had the regular haddock, but she probably could have done with a half order."

- Amy W.

"Friday night we decided to try a new place for fish. The place is very nice looking inside and appears that it had been remodeled recently. A haddock plate and Combo plate were ordered. It comes with coleslaw, choice of potato (fries, baby reds, baked potato or potato salad), as well as rye bread with onion. The combo plate comes with haddock, perch and shrimp. The haddock plate was ordered with 4 pieces. The sizes of the pieces are all different. Some were your standard thick pieces and others were large and flat. I appreciate that they use the whole filets, however the flatter pieces were cooked the same amount at the thicker pieces which made the thinner pieces over cooked and tough. The thicker pieces were good and the fish was flaky. The shrimp on the combo plate was really good as far as the cook and so was the perch. The breading that is used is a panko breading and was seasoned minimally. The breading was a nice amount on the fish and was very crispy. The coleslaw was basically flavorless and was dry. They also didn't provide onion for the rye bread with any of the orders which was five different dinners."

- Ashley

"Food is great. 1/4lb. The burger is big enough for me and an order of fries wow. The kicker was we each had a bowl of delicious chicken dumpling soup. Huge bowl and so filling with nice big dumplings, it really filled us up. There was only enough room for half of the hamburger and some fries. The place is somewhat noisy and the table was very tippy and rocked. The servers were fantastic and friendly"

- Richard R.

"First time eating here after the re-opening (new owners took over and did a lot of remodeling). Menu doesn't look like it changed alot. Had "cod" father sandwich and it's very good just like previously (picture included). Food was very good."

- Connie B.

"First visit since new ownership and remodel. Very nicely updated and an extensive menu. Food was nicely prepared (we had a Rueben and Cochinita Torta)."

- Douglas J.
Write a Review

Why Visit

The Settlement Bar & Grill is a must-visit for several reasons. First, the fish fry steals the show, featuring fresh perch and flaky haddock. Even regulars rave about this classic dish, ensuring satisfaction with every bite.

Taco Tuesday offers a delightful twist to the usual fare. The cochinita pibil tacos deliver bold, savory flavors that leave diners wanting more.

Enjoying a meal here means tapping into the friendly atmosphere. Staff members are known for their warmth and genuine hospitality. Table reservations ensure minimal wait during peak hours.

For anyone looking to unwind, this bar offers an excellent selection of craft beers and cocktails. The happy hour specials are a perfect opportunity to sample delicious drinks at great prices.

Lastly, the vibrant local community frequently gathers here, making it an excellent spot for people-watching and connecting with locals.

Most Liked things

The fish fry is a standout favorite. Its perfectly cooked fish and crispy fries leave diners satisfied. Many return just for this dish during Friday nights.

Another highlight is the inviting ambiance, making every visit feel like a gathering with friends.

Friendly and attentive service consistently earns praise from patrons, adding to a welcoming dining experience. Happy hour specials remain a great way to grab a drink without breaking the bank.

Most Disliked things

Some diners express concern about the noise levels during busy hours. The lively atmosphere might make conversations a bit challenging at peak times.

A few guests note that certain sides, like coleslaw, could use more flavor. This area has room for improvement, as many diners prefer bolder tastes with their meals.

On occasion, there can be long waits during dinner rushes, especially on Fridays, so visiting during off-peak hours may enhance the experience.

FAQ

What makes The Settlement Bar & Grill special?

The Settlement Bar & Grill stands out for its historical charm. Great fish fry and old fashions attract local patrons. The cozy environment welcomes families and groups. A friendly staff makes every visit memorable.

What are some must-try dishes?

Don't miss the Philly Steak Sandwich on Monday. It’s loaded with flavor. On Tuesdays, enjoy a classic burger basket, perfect for a casual meal. For a hearty option, try the Reuben on Wednesdays.

Is there a happy hour at The Settlement?

Yes, happy hour specials are available. Enjoy discounts on food and drinks during specific hours. It’s a perfect time to try new cocktails or grab a bite with friends.

What is the price range for meals?

The Settlement offers great value. Most dishes range from $1.88 to $7.25. With an average price around $4.64, it’s budget-friendly for everyone looking for good food.

Is the restaurant accessible?

Absolutely, The Settlement Bar & Grill is wheelchair accessible. Restrooms meet accessibility standards, ensuring comfort for all guests. Everyone can enjoy the welcoming atmosphere.